When I Was the Greatest by Jason Reynolds is highly praised for its authentic voice and engaging narration, capturing the essence of urban teenage life. Critics appreciate the robust character development and relatable themes. However, some feel the plot is predictable. Overall, it's lauded as a compelling and impactful read for young adults.

Readers who enjoy The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas or All American Boys by Jason Reynolds and Brendan Kiely will appreciate When I Was the Greatest. This novel resonates with teens interested in contemporary urban settings, complex friendships, and overcoming adversities. Ideal for readers seeking a realistic and heartfelt coming-of-age story.

In When I Was the Greatest, Ali, a nearly 16-year-old living with his family in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn, befriends brothers Noodles and Needles. Navigating life amid poverty and personal challenges, they face pivotal moments during a party that strains their friendships and forces them to confront their values on family and loyalty. Sensitive topics include references to poverty, violent altercations, and criminal activities.

Gritty / Emotional / Hopeful / Challenging / Contemplative

- When I Was the Greatest is Jason Reynolds's debut novel, published in 2014, which marked the beginning of his prolific writing career focusing on young adult literature.
- Jason Reynolds was inspired to write the book based on his own experiences and the vibrant community he grew up in, showcasing real-life challenges faced by teens in urban settings.
- The cover of When I Was the Greatest features intricate illustrations of yarn, which is a symbolic element in the story, using art to highlight cultural and personal themes without giving away key plot details.

**Allen "Ali" Brooks**  
The first-person narrator and protagonist who loves boxing and is fiercely loyal to his friends and family. He demonstrates selflessness and expresses his emotions freely, influenced by his affectionate father.

**Roland "Noodles" James**  
Ali’s close friend, known for his quick temper and love for comics and drawing. Noodles struggles with his feelings toward his brother Needles and seeks to reconcile his resentment with the love he feels for him.

**Ricky "Needles" James**  
Noodles’s older brother who has Tourette’s syndrome, making him a reserved character who performs acts of kindness around his neighborhood. His condition challenges perceptions within the community and highlights his unique coping mechanisms.

**Jazmine "Jazz" Brooks**  
Ali’s 11-year-old sister, known for her humor and her bantering relationships within the family. Her interactions with Ali help showcase his loving nature and sense of responsibility.

**Doris Brooks**  
Ali and Jazz’s mother, a hardworking social worker who is a disciplinary yet loving presence. She educates Ali about Tourette’s syndrome and influences his approach to kindness and understanding.

**John Brooks**  
Ali and Jazz’s father, a career thief known for his affectionate nature despite his absence from the home. His character evolves throughout the story, gradually becoming more dependable for his family.

**Malloy**  
A Vietnam veteran and mentor to Ali, Malloy trains boys in boxing and teaches valuable life lessons through his experiences. He provides guidance and support while dealing with his own personal challenges.

**Kendall "Black"**  
Known as a "jackass of all trades," Black is an entrepreneur in Ali's neighborhood with various talents. His lifestyle and work challenge Ali’s perceptions of hustler culture.

**Janice James**  
The mother of Noodles and Needles, who plays a minor role in the story. A single parent, she is portrayed as failing to support her children emotionally and physically, contributing to family tension.

Jason Reynolds

Novel

Fiction

Guide

Study Guide

Teaching Guide

Before You Read

Explore When I Was the Greatest reviews, reading age recommendations, and essential genre and thematic details before you start reading.

Before You Read When I Was the Greatest | SuperSummary

title

content

Overview

Get ready to explore When I Was the Greatest and its meaning. Our full analysis and study guide provides an even deeper dive with character analysis and quotes explained to help you discover the complexity and beauty of this book.

When I Was the Greatest Summary and Study Guide

chapter

chapterType

section

Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapters 1-3

When I Was the Greatest Chapters 1-3 Summary & Analysis

Chapters 4-6

When I Was the Greatest Chapters 4-6 Summary & Analysis

Chapters 7-9

When I Was the Greatest Chapters 7-9 Summary & Analysis

Chapters 10-12

When I Was the Greatest Chapters 10-12 Summary & Analysis

Chapters 13-16

When I Was the Greatest Chapters 13-16 Summary & Analysis

character

Character Analysis

When I Was the Greatest Character Analysis

theme

Themes

When I Was the Greatest Themes

Symbols & Motifs

When I Was the Greatest Symbols & Motifs

Literary Devices

When I Was the Greatest Literary Devices

quote

citation

Important Quotes

When I Was the Greatest Important Quotes

primaryCharacter

Essay Topics

When I Was the Greatest Essay Topics

When I Was the Greatest Teaching Unit

Introduction

When I Was the Greatest Teacher Introduction

Before Reading

Reading Context

When I Was the Greatest Reading Context

During Reading

Reading Questions & Paired Texts

When I Was the Greatest Reading Questions & Paired Texts

Answer Key

When I Was the Greatest Reading Questions Answer Key

After Reading

Discussion/Analysis Prompt

When I Was the Greatest Discussion/Analysis Prompt

Activities

When I Was the Greatest Activities

Essay Questions

When I Was the Greatest Essay Questions

Exam Questions

When I Was the Greatest Cumulative Exam Questions

Exam Answer Key

When I Was the Greatest Exam Answer Key

When I Was the Greatest

Before You Read

Reviews & Readership

Review Roundup

Who Should Read When I Was the Greatest?

Reading Age

Book Details